Sunday, October 5, 2008
some questions
I really wish the textbook would go into more detail about how archeologists and art historians come to their conclusions about the meanings of certain symbols or rituals they discover. In particular, the interpretation of the scrolls on the genital region of the reliefs struck me as odd. I want to know what other information led to their conclusions and how our modern interpretation of symbols from our popular or global culture influence what we support as truth in cultures we can never fully understand. How much of their cultural picture is missing from their artistic expression? How truthfully can our own culture be represented from the objects we create? How much of this do we take into account when studying the past?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

4 comments:
The danzantes info helped a lot with my ponderings on the genital scrolls. I should have read that earlier..
Hi niki- I absolutely agree with you ...I think many authors particularly Miller tend to shy away from placing too much information because as of yet much of the research is tenous and changes and may not have been confirmed at the time of publication. Though now--most if not all scholars have confirmed teh danzantes theory.
The danzantes slab depictions of dead people with modified genitalia really freaked me out. Especially when after I started to fanaticize about how cool it would have been to live a life in mesoamerican times. After reading this, not so much.
I to feel that some of the interpretations are questionable or unsufficient, and because the book can not give more background to how they came to their conclusion I to doubt the text sometimes. Whne I was reading about the Danzantes I 'imagined' a interpretation of why the culture sculpted the danzante figures. I guess that these stones were placed in a public area to remind the population of the conciquences of illegal actions. Multalation is found in many cultures today and if society saw a constant reminder of this penalty then I hope they would think twice on commiting anything against the law.
Post a Comment